OMG! I got it!!!
Cool, glad this worked for you... lucky you had stored it on disk...
As I said there are two masterPassword/masterPasswordKeys in my .rdf files. When I tried the second one it worked! Hmmm... An older password for sure.
Are you sure? There should be only one in the 'globalSettings' section of the RDF file... if there is more than one, something is definitely awry...
Now how to I change it?
It sounds like you still aren't crystal clear on how this works...
You don't change it... just make a note of it so you don't forget it again, then change the 'Store Master Password' option to 'Not at all' - this will delete the saved one from the RDF file, and now you can use whatever you want when prompted. If you only use one, and are ok with the risk of storing it on disk (someone else with physical access to your PC could discover your Master Password the same way you just did)
Remember... the ability to store it is for convenience only, and really is NOT recommended, since it is a security risk.
Also, if you choose to use more than one Master Password, storing the Master Password, will effectively disable the option to 'Use more than one Master Password', which I do - I use different Master Passwords based on account types - one MPW for financial related sites, another for webmail accounts, etc...